The Monte Hall Effect cover art

The Monte Hall Effect

The Monte Hall Effect

By: Tim Lloyd Tola Marts
Listen for free

Tim Lloyd and Tola Marts are two leaders in the Seattle aerospace community with over forty years of experience between them dealing with aerospace and high tech issues. They're also avid film buffs, and in each podcast they'll take a different science fiction film and discuss three key facets: *Science: How well do the scientific ideas in the film reflect real science. *Fiction: Do the film's plot and characterization take the viewer on a fun or intriguing journey? And… *Film: Does the movie make the most of cinematography, so that it works better in conveying its ideas than it would in a book, or graphic novel, or play? At the end of each podcast they’ll give the film a percentage ratings for each of those facets. NOTE: there will be spoilers for the film being discussed, but they will try to keep spoilers for other films to a minimum. The podcast theme music- intro and outro- is written and performed by Guy Ellis, and more of his music can be found at https://soundcloud.com/gu42 and https://www.facebook.com/cloudcoverband/.© 2026 The Monte Hall Effect Art Science
Episodes
  • 18: Project Hail Mary
    May 26 2026

    Tola and Tim are joined by Leigh Shocki to discuss Phil Lord and Christopher Miller's Project Hail Mary. Final score: Science 77, Fiction 87, Film 88.
    Up next: Sorry to Bother You

    Special Guest: Leigh Shocki.

    Show More Show Less
    2 hrs and 24 mins
  • 17: Blade Runner 2049
    Apr 8 2026

    Tola and Tim discuss (yet another Denis Villeneuve film) Blade Runner 2049. Tim struggles to make connections from Tola’s list of actors to Blade Runner and 2001. The guys discuss sequels, opening text, Vangelis, Ryan Gosling’s eyes, Dave Bautista’s tiny glasses, Princess Buttercup, Nabokov (thanks to Priscilla Page’s excellent essay for this connection The Poetry of Blade Runner 2049), miming vs feeling humanity, AI girlfriends, the Joi of Ana de Armas, Jared Leto’s Elon Musk-ian scene-chewing and monologues on slavery, the joy of an Edward James Olmos cameo, the complicated ickiness of consent in Blade Runner (thanks to El Zee’s essay The Impossibility of Consent), questions about production lines for replicants, why we choose to watch movies that recapitulate terribleness, Sorry to Bother You, Manic Pixie Dream Sexbots, Take Your AI Girlfriend To Work Day, junkyard kite harpoons, failure modes of hovercars, implanted memories, extra creepy holographic sexbots, Chekhov’s hard drive, Minneapolis’s Somali theater contingent, the emotions of a murderbot, radioactive Las Vegas and its giant statues of sex workers, Roger Deakins’ amazing cinematography, more objectification and commoditization of women, Deckard’s bees, feeding whiskey to a dog, drinks over fistfights, changes in how we interpret films over time, fighting in the sea while a car slowly goes underwater, and tears in snow.
    Final score: science 65%, fiction 73%, film 91%.
    Next up: Project Hail Mary (more Gosling!)

    Show More Show Less
    2 hrs and 28 mins
  • 16: Fantastic Four: First Steps
    Feb 14 2026

    It's the Fantastic Four! We recorded this so long ago that we don't have a helpful description to write here.
    Many many thanks to Paul Zastrow for audio engineering this episode.
    Final score: science 50%, fiction 60%, film 80%
    Next up: Blade Runner 2049

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 41 mins
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet