The Ghost in the Mailbox: The Circleville Writer cover art

The Ghost in the Mailbox: The Circleville Writer

The Ghost in the Mailbox: The Circleville Writer

Listen for free

View show details

In 1976, the residents of the small town of Circleville, Ohio, began receiving vicious, anonymous letters filled with intimate secrets, threats, and graphic accusations. What started as a targeted smear campaign against a local school bus driver quickly spiraled into an absolute nightmare involving booby-trapped pistols, a suspicious fatal car crash, and an alleged cover-up.

Even after a suspect was caught and sent to prison, the letters kept coming. Who was the true mastermind behind the pen? Was the wrong man convicted, or was the writer a collective entity watching the town's every move? This week, we dive deep into the eerie, decades-long mystery of the anonymous author who held an entire community hostage without ever showing their face.

In This Episode, We Discuss:

  • The targeted campaign against Mary Gillispie and the town's reaction.
  • The tragic death of Ron Radcliff and the bizarre booby trap that followed.
  • The trial of Paul Freshour: Is he the guilty writer, or a framed man?
  • The chilling theories that still linger over Circleville today
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
No reviews yet