A movie about a dog show somehow turns into a full-on personality test, and our reactions could not be more different. We’re talking Best in Show, Christopher Guest’s mockumentary where the dogs are basically props and the real comedy is watching adults melt down over pride, status, and tiny mistakes. One of us sees brilliant ensemble work hiding under the chaos; the other sees peak unserious behavior and keeps asking the same question: where is the story?

We get into what makes this film so distinctive: the heavily improvised style, the stacked cast (Eugene Levy, Catherine O’Hara, Parker Posey, Jennifer Coolidge, Jane Lynch), and the way each handler becomes an exaggerated type you’ve met in real life. We also nerd out on details like the real championship dogs, how the production recreated a full dog show environment on a modest budget, and why some jokes land harder once you know what the movie is trying to do.

And yes, we spend plenty of time on the MVP conversation. Fred Willard’s commentary is so confidently wrong it becomes the perfect running gag, and it might be the single best argument for giving the movie your attention. We wrap with our full rating breakdown across plot, acting, production, sound, and cultural impact, plus the final score that puts this one in rare company on our list.

If you enjoy movie debates, improvised comedy, and honest reviews that aren’t afraid to disagree, hit play, then subscribe, share the show with a friend, and leave us a review with your take: genius or nonsense?

Send us Fan Mail

Support the show

Follow us on the following social media platforms or email us at reeltalkbanter@gmail.com!

Facebook

Instagram

Twitter

YouTube

TikTok