• Bart of Darkness with Ben Russell
    Jun 25 2026

    Today we're reviewing Season 6 Episode 1 of The Simpsons "Bart of Darkness". This is the one where Bart breaks his leg and descends into Rear Window-esque paranoia.

    We're joined by Australian comedian and actor Ben Russell. He discusses the joys of having a pool growing up, breaking his wrist, and we all reminisce about our time doing comedy in Chicago.

    You can follow Ben at imbenrussell on Instagram. You can follow this show at bartannicapod as well.

    Ben Recommends Star Trek TOS Rear Window

    Eli Recommends Star Trek: TNG

    Harrison Recommends Contested Waters: A Social History of Swimming Pools in America by Jeff Wiltse Going Swimming Dames by Busby Berkeley

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 47 mins
  • Three Men and a Comic Book with David Cooper
    Jun 11 2026

    We're reviewing Episode 21 of Season 2 of the Simpsons, "Three Men and a Comic Book"; Bart raises money to buy a comic, then eventually splits the cost with Martin and Milhouse.

    Our guest is artist David Cooper. David is currently on a mission to draw every Simpsons character ever. We discuss his work, why the Simpsons succeeds as a satire of other sitcoms, and how a Humphrey Bogart movie completely changed the way we see the episode's 3rd act.

    Follow David at davidbcooper on Instagram. You can follow this show at bartannicapod on Instagram as well.

    David Recommends The Radioactive Man comic books by Bongo

    Eli Recommends Going to a comic book convention

    Harrison Recommends Treasures of the Sierra Madre

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 22 mins
  • Home Sweet Homediddly-Dum-Doodily with Mads Horwath
    May 28 2026

    We're discussing a classic episode with a true Simpsons fanatic, Mads Horwath (New Yorker, Guardian). They tell an insane story about tricking their classmates into a Simpsons-related prank, we discuss the weird feeling of visiting other peoples' homes and why the stakes are so high in this episode- it threatens the very nature of the Simpsons' being!

    We are reviewing Season 7 Episode 3 Home Sweet Homediddly-Dum-Doodily from October 1995- this is the one where Bart, Lisa and Maggie are taken to the Flanders for foster care as Marge and Homer fight to regain custody. Stupid Babies Need the Most Attention, America Loves Ted Kennedy, and we love this episode!

    Follow Mads @madelinehorwath to see their cartoons and also to order a pet portrait with all proceeds going to help people in need in Gaza.

    Follow this show at bartannicapod on Instagram and WATCH THE FULL EP ON YT starting next week! Exciting! Mads recommends: Detectorists

    Harrison Recommends: Chucky 2

    Eli Recommends: Paco

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 48 mins
  • Lisa's Date with Density with Devin Leary
    May 14 2026

    We've got a very special episode with a special guest- Eli's fiancée, Devin Leary (THIRST TRAP, The Quiz Show with Julia and Devin). We are discussing Season 8 Episode 7 of the Simpsons "Lisa's Date with Density", where Lisa gets a crush on Nelson Muntz! We talk about the good girl/bad boy trope, our own experiences dating the wrong person, and Harrison watches Rebel Without a Clue.

    You can follow Devin at devin_hunter_leary on socials and her substack at: lightdisorder.substack.com. Listen to The Quiz Show with Julia and Devin wherever you get your podcasts.

    Devin Recommends: Gilmore Girls

    Eli Recommends: Getting Engaged

    Harrison Recommends: 10 Things I Hate About You

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 43 mins
  • Lost Our Lisa With Megan Nolan
    Apr 30 2026

    Today we're reviewing a very sweet Simpsons episode, and we have a very sweet guest to boot. We're discussing Season 9 Episode 24 "Lost our Lisa" with guest Megan Nolan (Acts of Desperation, Ordinary Human Failings).

    We discuss her 2 novels and how she created such a compelling characters. We also talk about the father-daughter relationship at the heart of the episode, and what traits we'd want to instill in Lisa if we were Homer.

    We also talk A LOT about Egyptian museum exhibits and buses. And Eli talks about his recent trip to Italy!

    You can follow Megan at mmegannolan on Instagram. You can follow this show at bartannicapod.

    Megan Recommends: Cider House Rules Harrison and Eli Recommend: Going to museums Reading Megan's books!

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 25 mins
  • Marge Vs the Monorail with Mike Finn
    Apr 9 2026

    Today we're covering one of the best Simpsons episodes of all time, Season 4 Episode 12 "Marge Vs the Monorail" and we have one of the best people in the whole world as a guest, Mike Finn.

    Mike, Harrison and Eli used to do improv as Cool Jacket and have been friends for over a decade. We talk about what Mike does (and doesn't) want his kids watching (including KPop Demon Hunters), watching The Simpsons on The Tracey Ullman Show, and our shared love of watching grass grow.

    We also debate if Monorail is truly the best episode of The Simpsons, how the town of Springfield should probably just get some new buses, and Eli and Harrison BOTH read a book about Genghis Khan!

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 38 mins
  • A Star is Burns with Matt Crowe
    Mar 26 2026

    This week we have one of Harrison's oldest friends, Matt Crowe, on the show! Harrison and Matt have been friends for over 20 years and during that time they've shared over roughly 1,000 Simpsons memes, quotes and clips with each other. It only made sense to have him on the pod to discuss this great episode.

    Today we're discussing Season 6 Episode 18 A Star is Burns- this is is the one where Jay Sherman (The Critic) stops by to judge a Springfield film festival: football in the groin, Don't Cry For Me I'm Already Dead, and Boo-urns.

    We discuss Matt's love of rewatching old shows, his sense of humor as a nurse, and I discuss some of the MANY movies I watched this week that are referenced in the episode.

    Matt Recommends: Tallgrass Film Festival The Critic

    Eli Recommends: Siskel and Ebert Reviews

    Harrison Recommends: Reel Politk by Nathan Gelgud A Man for All Seasons (movie and play)

    Show More Show Less
    1 hr and 24 mins
  • Brother From the Same Planet with Clayton Margeson
    Mar 12 2026

    Today we're talking about the classic Simpsons' episode from Season 4, Episode 14 and we've got our first ever RETURNING GUEST Clayton Margeson!! The 3 of us discuss why this is the best Simpsons episode we've reviewed so far: "I Love You, Pepsi", Krusty's terrible SNL appearance, and Tom, the perfect Big Brother, full of barely contained rage.

    We also talk about why the "Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf" jokes don't land, Jesus as a hog-caller, and the history of 1900 numbers.

    Follow Clayton at king.claz on Instagram, and this show at bartannicapod.

    Clayton Recommends: "In Pieces" by Sally Fields Jack Frost- the movie about Michael Keaton as a CGI snowman who looks like George Clooney

    Eli Recommends: The Public Enemy starring James Cagney Taking Improv Classes with Clayton

    Harrison Recommends: Taking Improv Classes with Clayton The kids movie triptych: Mrs. Doubtfire, Liar Liar and the Santa Clause

    References: The Sun Won't Come Out Tomorrow: The Dark History of American Orphanhood by Kristen Martin 1900-Cry Commercial Indiana Jones Bad Nazi Face Melting Behind the Scenes The Tommy Westphall Extended Universe

    Show More Show Less
    2 hrs and 3 mins