“Where does Stuart end and Jesse begin?”

Just one of the existential questions we posited during our discussion of the meta masterwork that is New Nightmare (1994)—a movie that absolutely walked so Scream (1996) could run! Press play to hear our full thoughts (and another Madame Web tangent) on this series standout!

Peep this:

We’re kicking off the month with the grossly underrated Peeping Tom (1960), a movie which follows a cameraman who can’t stop scaring his victims to literal death on camera. With numerous “pov” shots, sequences featuring Sinister-esque home videos, and raunchy bodegas, this one’s for the freaks (and we really enjoyed chatting about it). Press play now!

Obsession? More like obsessed!

We saw (and loved) Curry Barker’s new buzzy film about a sad boy who basically lets a violently clingy genie out of a bottle. Press play to hear our full thoughts!

The Crimson is peeking!

Ciara Myst is back this week chatting with us about Guillermo del Toro’s ridiculously stylized/atmospheric/horny 2015 ghost story. Press play for musings on the clay industry (?), Tom Hiddleston butt, and some supernatural encounters of our own.

Put yourselves on Do Not Disturb, people! This week, we have RPDR Season 18 diva Ciara Myst on the pod chatting Crimson Peak (2015)! Before we dive into that gloriously kinky ghost story, though, Ciara walks us through her history as an Android user, her Indiana drag origins, and the healing power of watching Predator during your flight. Also, do yourselves a favor and dial in to the video portion of the interview because Ciara’s look is LEGENDARY!!

“Last night, I dreamt of listening to Another Gay Horror Pod.”

If you said this to yourself (or others) recently, we super appreciate it, and we’d highly recommend you check out our Rebecca (1940) episode. Actually, if you’re reading this, chances are you’re already aware of the ep so do yourself a favor and press Play!! And yes, Jesse once again managed to insert Silent Hill discourse into the conversation.

This week, we’re getting loud for The Silence of the Lambs! Press play to hear our musings on the 1991 Best Picture winner, which includes Stuart’s Clarice Starling impersonation, Jesse’s attempts to recollect his West Virginia origins, and more! Do all beans taste the same? Press play to find out!

New Intro, Old Episode. Enjoy a flashback to last march as we talk gallons of milk, Wicked and Psycho.